Metacognition: What Is It?
As a general rule at Condor Performance, we try to avoid too much psychobabble. Psychobabble describes the countless psychological terms that most people would never have heard of. Classic examples of sport psychology psychobabble might include terms such as diffusion, reframing, and contraindication!
Unfortunately, with the term metacognition, we can use no other word instead. Overthinking may come close, but it’s not quite the same.
Metacognition is ‘the human brain’s ability to think about thoughts’.
This is quite unusual and unique across the Animal Kingdom. Thinking about thinking requires knowledge of the cognitions that exist in the first place. Don’t get me wrong. Most primates, such as chimpanzees, also possess complicated thought processes. But they probably have them, and that’s it. They don’t try to do anything with these thoughts like we do.
Metacognition for humans is primarily functional. Our ability to reflect on our thoughts allows us to be far more creative and patient than most other species. However, from a performance psychology point of view, it can produce issues.
Metacognition: Why Is It An Issue?
The nitty-gritty of why metacognition can be problematic from a mental side of performance boils down to the connection between the thinking and doing parts of our brain. Most readers will agree that once a performer has notched up enough hours of repetition for their particular set of motor skills, then no thought is required anymore.
The experienced surgeon doesn’t need to think “be steady” when holding the scruple close to the incision point. Elite netballers do not have to think of “soft hands” just before the moment in which they receive the ball from a teammate.
This is different from those who are only learning these motor skills. Before muscle memory has been established, it may be helpful to think of all sorts of related things to remember the correct technique. Please note I used the word helpful here, not essential.
Most thoughts, the natural ones in particular, when they occur simultaneously as the elite performer is executing their well-rehearsed skills, will have no bearing on the consistency of these movements. Even irrelevant thoughts such as “I hope my Mum is watching” are acceptable and harmless to well-practised motor skills.
💡 The Struggle Switch 😬
The issues start when we incorrectly believe that our thoughts play a key role in the success of these performance actions. This can play out in several ways. The performers may believe they need to think a certain way to perform a certain way. A Struggle Switch comes with this erroneous (more psychobabble, sorry) belief. Suddenly, negative thoughts (wholly normal and potentially harmless – see below) become the primary focus.
Neuroscientists are still trying to determine precisely what happens in these instances, but some switch seems to occur. In other words, although the muscle memory of the well-rehearsed actions still exists, it appears to be switched off temporarily whilst the blood flow is diverted from the cerebellum and towards the front lobe.
Of course, this has a massively negative impact on performance consistency, and unfortunately, in many cases, the performer and those supporting him or her blame the negative thoughts. But it was not their fault.
Metacognition: How To Manage It
Suppose we use the concept above of The Struggle Switch in simple terms. In that case, some aspect of the performance practice needs to be unapologetically about getting better at accepting thoughts (yes, all of them) rather than struggling with them.
Some form of mindfulness regularly is likely to be the best way of learning the basics of becoming less susceptible to metacognition in performance situations. It might be better to be guided by a qualified and experienced professional to start mastering this whilst practising.
The current Condor Performance team is a professional group based in Australia and New Zealand that consults across the English-speaking world.
You can view their profile via this link and then reach out to our Intake team via this one.
